How to Be an Expressivist about Avowals Today

Ángel García Rodríguez

Abstract


According to expressivism about avowals, the meaning of typical self-ascriptions of mental states is a matter of expressing an attitude, rather than describing a state of affairs. Traditionally, expressivism has been glossed as the view that, qua expressions, avowals are not truth-evaluable. Contemporary neoexpressivists like Finkelstein and Bar-On have argued that avowals are expressions, and truth-evaluable besides. In contrast, this paper provides a defence of the view that avowals are, qua expressions, truth-evaluable. This defence is based on an argument from disagreement, to the effect that an adequate explanation of the existence of disagreement involving both cases of avowals and cases of nonlinguistic expression (like winces) supports a view according to which genuine (sincere, truthful) expression is what truth amounts to in avowals.

Keywords


20th century philosophy; Wittgenstein Ludwig; avowal; expression; truth; truthfulness; Finkelstein David; Bar-On Dorit

Full Text:

PDF HTML

References


Bar-On, D., 2004. Speaking my mind. Oxford UP.

Bar-On, D. & Long, D.C., 2001. “Avowals and first-person privilege”. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, LXII, pp. 311-335.

Blackburn, S., 1984. Spreading the word. Oxford UP.

Blackburn, S., 2009. “The landscapes of pragmatism”. Teorema, XXVIII/3, pp. 31-48.

Blackburn, S., 2010. Practical tortoise raising and other philosophical essays. Oxford UP.

Carnap, R., 1935/1996. Philosophy and logical syntax. Reprinted by Thoemmes Press.

Finkelstein, D., 2003. Expression and the inner. Harvard UP.

Finkelstein, D., 2010. “Expression and avowal”. In: K. Jolley, ed. Wittgenstein: key concepts. Durham: Acumen, pp. 185-198.

Green, M., 2007. Self-expression. Oxford UP.

Hacker, P.M.S., 1986. Insight and illusion. Oxford UP.

Wittgenstein, L., 2001. Philosophical investigations. Oxford: Blackwell. Revised English translation by G.E.M. Anscombe.

Wright, C., 2001. “The problem of self-knowledge” (II). In: Rails to infinity. Harvard UP, pp. 345-373.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Bookmark and Share